Wednesday, September 28, 2005

standards and rules

I've been thinking about standards and whether they are confining or not. I guess that depends on the standard and the person involved. Where I work we have quite a few standards: food safety, personal safety, and food presentation being the biggest three. But sometimes it seems like a standard is more like a rule, and then it gets to be a little confining. For example, a girl who works with me has a nose ring, which doesn't come out anymore, and since she cannot remove it she has to wear a large, blue, company issued bandaid over it. It looks rediculous and isn't exactly what I would want the person who is serving my food to have on their face. The point is, there is a rule that no one in the food prep or serving area can wear jewelry. There is another standart we have to abide by, concerning cookies. We have to have four kinds of regular size cookies, two kinds of large cookies, and one cookie of the week, in this order from bottom to top, in the cookie rack at all times. This to me seems almost as bad as the bandaid, if we know people only eat two kinds of cookies and ignore the rest, then we are forced to waste the rest. It, in its own way is confining. So what is the difference between a standard and a rule here?

Another thought is that standards, like codes, are created by both society in general and governing bodies. Dress codes could be considered a standard, I guess, so everyone at a company would have to dress in the same type of outfit. This is imposed by the business, but how they wear those clothes is determined by a societal standard. If they dressed in any but the common practice they would be ridiculded, so we mostly follow this same pattern. But, even though some standards could get in our way, I think it is good that we have them in place. In the justice system standards are what makes it "fair" to stand in front of a judge. He is suppossed to view your case and hold it up to a set standard for punishment, keeping his prejudice from affecting your sentance. The example of the traffic lights is a good one. This is a standard that really doesn't affect anyone, but it does make the world a lot easier to navigate. Just like the standards for web page design, I don't think they are there to choke the life out of me, but to help the world navigate the internet easier.

So, the big question is: When , or how, does a standard become a rule (or a law for that matter), and does that standard or rule really affect me? I'm sure there are more standards than I could ever know about, but I've never ran into them because they don't affect me.

I'll step off my little box now so you don't have to read any more of my rambling.

Rob.

3 comments:

Julie V. said...

So, maybe a difference between code and standard is that one is more covert than the other?

I really liked some of the examples you gave and I think you could definitely add those ideas to the Wiki!

I tend to agree with Kate on the difference between rules and standards. But, couldn't another difference be that there are definite consequences to breaking rules or laws (in most cases & if you get caught) and there aren't really any set punishments or absolute consequences for breaking standards?

An example: If you live with your parents and they have a rule that your curfew is 10 P.M., but you come home at 10:30 P.M., you will probably have a consequence for this action (grounding, etc.). Or, there is a rule at school against copying other students' work and there are definite consequences there.

If you steal a compute from Wal-Mart and get caught, you have broken the law and there are obvious consequences. You would probably go to jail and have to pay a lot of money. Or if you speed in your car (to use Kate's example of driving), you know what the consequences are.

However, there is a standard (of behavior in this case) that we don't sleep in the elevator at school. Is there really a solid consequence for this behavior? Maybe there is and I don't know about it, but I don't think so.

Julie V. said...

Hmmmm. . .I think I'll pass on the sleeping in the elevator thing, although $20 does sound mighty appealing. :)

Rob said...

Trisha, when you find one you let me know. I've been trying to find an example myself.

Rob.